The Best STL Pizza Competition Featuring Pizza Babble and BradenSTL
Mostly Superheroes the Podcast proudly presents The Best STL Pizza Competition the Podcast hosted by Logan Janis, Arena Andy, Scotty Scoop and Sam the Sleeper from Team Jakey featuring Pizza Babble and BradenSTL. Sponsored Exclusively by The Gramophone AKA The Sandwichkingz. Nine St. Louis pizzas battle for first place, plus the crew features Pizza Babble's list of St. Louis pizza spots totaling in more than 130! Also listen for two passwords in the episode to win amazing prizes. All this and more from you friendly independent podcast, Mostly Superheroes.
00:00:00 - Introduction
00:01:07 - Pizza Competition Overview
00:01:37 - Sponsor Shoutout: The Gramophone
00:02:57 - Scotty's Pizza: Plank Road
00:03:17 - Arena Andy's Pizza: Pirrones
00:04:41 - Arena Andy's Pizza: South Side Pie from Onesto
00:05:19 - Braden's Pizza: Nickys Slices
00:06:15 - Pizza Babble's Pizza: Montebello
00:07:00 - Logan's Pizza: Katie's Pizza
00:08:01 - Sam's Pizza: Blues City Deli & Dogtown Pizza
00:10:05 - New Studio Setup
00:11:02 - Pizza Competition Rules
00:12:11 - Favorite Gramophone Sandwiches
00:18:10 - Pizza Competition Rankings
00:27:10 - Scotty's Rankings
00:29:59 - Brad's Rankings
00:32:11 - Pizza Babble's Rankings
00:34:12 - Pizza Competition Results
00:35:02 - Final Thoughts on Pizza
00:40:13 - Pizza Places in St. Louis
00:46:44 - Fan Shoutouts
00:50:29 - Upcoming Events
00:55:36 - Team Jakey Overview
01:00:37 - Stranger Things Discussion
01:05:01 - Movie Pizza Scenes
01:09:03 - Final Goodbyes
Thank you to The Gramophone in The Grove in St. Louis for making this episode possible. Learn more and order online at http://www.gramophonestl.com/.
Follow @mostlysuperheroes, @PizzaBabble, and @bradenSTL for more food, fun, and events.
Thank you to our patrons who supports us and get early ad-free episodes. Sign up at https://mostlysuperheroes.com/support.
Learn more about Team Jakey at www.teamjakey.org.
Thank you to every St. Louis pizza joint out there. Go out and support your local pizza place!
Subscribe to our free monthly newsletter, our podcast, and YouTube channel all linked up at www.mostlysuperheroes.com.
©2025 Carrogan Studios
Join us for the Best Saint Louis Pizza Competition 2025! We're bringing together the top pizza places in town, including Dogtown Pizza, Katie's Pizza, Imo's, Nicky's Pizza, Montebello Pizzeria, and many more. Hosted by Mostly Superheroes the Podcast featuring Pizza Babble and BradenSTL. This episode promises delicious fun and exciting surprises. Brought to you by The Gramophone in the Grove AKA The Sandwich Kings. Don't miss out on the chance to vote for your favorite pizza below! You could be featured in the episode. Subscribe to Mostly Superheroes now so you don't miss this episode!
PLUS Enter to Win a model-sized Surfer Boy Pizza Delivery Van from Stranger Things as we get ready for Stranger Things Season 5! To enter, send password PIZZA with your favorite pizza and you are entered!
Entries counted for every one of the follow completed:
Comment on this post
Follow @mostlysuperheroes, @thegramophone, @pizzababble, and @bradenstl
Text 754 CALL LOG
DM @mostlysuperheroes on IG or FB
Contact us at mostlysuperheroes.com
BONUS ENTRES FOR EACH:
Share this post!
Subscribe to the FREE Monthly Newsletter at mostlysuperheroes.com
Leave a genuine podcast or YouTube review of Mostly Superheroes
Must be 18+ to participate, terms, conditions, and rates apply.
Learn more, subscribe, and support at mostlysuperheroes.com.
©2025 Carrogan Studios.
Join Mostly Superheroes Live every Friday on YouTube, Facebook, and Instagram for contests, Events, TV & FIlm Reviews, and Surprise interviews. Bookmark this page to check out preview Friday Live sessions.
Podcast SPONSORS
Access to Early & Ad-Free Episodes Plus Exclusive Content.
